Study Skills Ace
  • Home
  • About
  • Proofreading
  • Consulting
  • Study Skills Advice
    • Relaxing study videos

How to Write Better Essays (Part 2: How to Answer Questions)

10/2/2019

 
In this video, Tim Squirrell (University of Edinburgh), explains how to answer the questions posed by an undergraduate university essay.

Answering the question

Summary: identify key terms in the question, define those terms, question the question (what are the assumptions behind it?).
​
Some questions are straightforward. They might ask you to ‘critically assess’ some claim or concept, or ask you a simple question which you’ll have to answer in a complex way. Other questions aren’t so simple. They’ll make a statement and tell you to discuss it. They might ask you to compare and contrast two different ideas, or say which of two theories is the more accurate. We’ll talk about both types of questions here.

  1. Identify the key terms in the question. If the question is “what is the best solution to the demarcation problem?”, you’re going to want to identify what you think the examiner means by the terms ‘solution’ and ‘demarcation problem’. How are you going to define and operationalise those terms in your essay? This is essential, because your argument has to have a clear definition of the terms you’re using in order for it to be coherent and responsive. This doesn’t mean you should use lazy constructions like “I am going to define ‘demarcation problem’ as ‘the question of how we can define ‘science””. That’s a perfectly reasonable definition (if you can defend it, and you should give a reason you’ve chosen a certain definition), but you need to be a little less clunky. Something like “When we talk about the problem of demarcation, we refer to the question of how exactly we can define ‘science’ as a sphere of human activity which is somehow special”, will do just fine.
  2. Question the question. You’ll hear this quite a lot, and you’ll probably wonder what on earth it means. It’s important to understand it, because it can be the key to getting a high mark. Every term in a question is ambiguous. Every question has hidden assumptions behind it. You can question these assumptions. For example, in the question about ‘the demarcation problem’ above, there are assumptions that there is a single problem of demarcation, as well as a single best solution to that problem. Sometimes it’s enough to point out that these assumptions exist, and then to proceed with the essay by clarifying the definitions you’re using and the assumptions you’re working with. Sometimes you might think that the assumptions are fundamentally mistaken, or disguise a more important question. In that case, you’ll need to point this out, and then proceed to explain why, and to make your arguments within the essay using your revised understanding of the question.
  3. If the question is “X statement. Discuss.” then you have, broadly, four options on how to answer it – see below. Try not to hedge your bets: this isn’t AS Level Critical Thinking, you don’t need to give both sides equal weighting and say “ooh, it’s a really tricky question and there are great arguments on both sides”. Have opinions.
    1. This is true, and that’s great
    2. This is true, and that’s awful
    3. This isn’t true, and it should be true
    4. This isn’t true, and that’s fine.
  4. How are you going to relate your argument to the existing literature? Who are the key authors you plan to draw on? Make sure you know their arguments reasonably well and have armed yourself with flexible quotes from their work. If you can, familiarise yourself with the people who think they’re wrong and awful. Figure out if there are arguments which are unresolved and see if you can make a contribution towards resolving them.

Once you’ve clarified all the terms, you can start to put together your arguments and write the essay.

​Please follow the links below to the relevant videos and transcripts:
  • How to Write Better Essays (Part 1: Reading)
  • ​How to Write Better Essays (Part 2: How to Answer Questions)
  • ​How to Write Better Essays (Part 3: Structure)
  • ​How to Write Better Essays (Part 4: Analysis)
  • ​How to Write Better Essays (Part 5: Using Evidence)

Comments are closed.
    Picture
    Proofreading
    Consulting
    Study Advice

    Archives

    January 2023
    February 2019

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed

Home
​
About
Proofreading

Consulting
Study Skills Advice
Picture
​Contact
Terms & conditions
Privacy policy
​​© All rights reserved, Study Skills Ace
Admin login
  • Home
  • About
  • Proofreading
  • Consulting
  • Study Skills Advice
    • Relaxing study videos